Every feud story needs a romance, and the Hatfield-McCoy feud has one ready-made: the son of one family head and the daughter of the other, meeting across a river and a grudge. The tale of Johnse Hatfield and Roseanna McCoy has been told in ballads, novels, films and television series, and with each telling it has grown more polished. The surviving record is thinner and sadder than the legend, and it is worth separating the two.
Who they were
Johnse Hatfield was one of the older sons of Devil Anse Hatfield and his wife Levicy, born around 1862 on the West Virginia side of the Tug. He is remembered as handsome, easy-going and fond of women and whiskey, and he lacked his father's steadiness.
Roseanna McCoy was a daughter of Randolph and Sarah McCoy, born around 1859 or 1860 on the Kentucky side. Very little was written down about her in her own lifetime, and most of what is said about her character comes from later tellings. She is usually described as pretty and gentle, which may be true but cannot be checked.
The election day meeting of 1880
The two are said to have met at an election-day gathering in 1880, the kind of social occasion that brought young people from both sides of the river together. The story goes that they talked through the day, that Roseanna missed her chance to leave with her family, and that she went home with Johnse to the Hatfield side.
She lived for a time with the Hatfields. Devil Anse, by most accounts, did not object to her staying, but he would not agree to a marriage, and the reasons given vary: family pride, the bad blood with Randolph, or doubt about whether Johnse would settle down. Randolph McCoy was furious that his daughter had gone across the river.
It is worth remembering how young they were. Johnse was still in his teens or barely out of them, and Roseanna was only a little older. Neither had any power over the grown men whose quarrels now shaped their lives, and neither family seems to have asked what the two of them wanted for the long term.
After some months Roseanna went back to Kentucky, though she did not return to her father's house; accounts say she stayed with an aunt.
The arrest and the midnight ride
The most famous scene in the romance comes next. Johnse crossed the river to see Roseanna and was arrested by some of her brothers on old moonshining or weapons warrants. The story goes that Roseanna, fearing he would be killed, rode bareback through the night to Devil Anse to warn him, and that the Hatfields overtook the McCoys and freed Johnse.
Another stop · Pike CountyThe 1878 hog trialSome version of this happened: Johnse was taken and then released after Hatfields arrived. The details of the ride, the weather, the horse and what was said are the parts most likely to have been embroidered. Some tellings also claim that Johnse, once free, left Roseanna without a word, which turned her from heroine to wronged woman in the story.
A child and a marriage to Nancy McCoy
Roseanna was pregnant. She gave birth to a daughter, usually named as Sarah Elizabeth, who died in infancy; most accounts say of measles. Johnse did not marry her.
In 1881 Johnse instead married Nancy McCoy, Roseanna's cousin, a daughter of Asa Harmon McCoy, whose killing in 1865 many see as the root of the feud. The marriage was unhappy. Nancy later left Johnse and married Frank Phillips, the Pike County deputy who led the posses against the Hatfields in 1888. For a story already full of crossed loyalties, it is a remarkable twist, and it is one of the parts that is well supported.
Johnse took part in the New Year's raid of 1888, as told in New Year's night, 1888. Years later he was arrested, tried in Kentucky and sent to prison. A story often told, and hard to check, says he was pardoned after saving the life of a prison official. He was released and died in 1922.
Roseanna's last years and grave
Roseanna's later life is barely recorded. She is said to have lived quietly with relatives and to have been in poor health and low spirits. She died young, usually given as around 1889, while still in her late twenties. Later writers said she died of a broken heart, which says more about the legend than about any medical record.
She is buried in a small McCoy family cemetery on the Kentucky side of the Tug, on private land. If you hope to see the grave, do not walk onto the property; ask permission from the landowners or view it from the public road. Her parents' graves are in Pikeville, covered in Dils Cemetery, Pikeville.
How the legend grew
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, newspapers and popular writers turned the feud into a mountain melodrama, and the romance gave them a centre. Roseanna became a kind of Appalachian Juliet. Dialogue was invented, motives assigned and scenes staged, and many of those inventions passed into later books as fact.
What remains reliable is short. A young man and a young woman from the two families had a relationship, she lived for a time with his family, she had a child who died, he married her cousin, and she died young. Everything else is told with varying degrees of confidence. For the shape of the whole quarrel, see the feud in brief; for Roseanna's father, see Randolph McCoy.
