Randolph McCoy, often called Ole Ran'l in the old tellings, was the head of the McCoy family during the feud and the man who suffered most from it. He was a farmer on the Kentucky side of the Tug Fork, a stubborn and outspoken man by most accounts, and by the end of the 1880s he had buried five of his children who died by violence connected to the quarrel. His story is a hard one to tell, and it deserves telling plainly.
A farmer on Blackberry Creek
Randolph McCoy was born in 1825 in the Tug Valley, into one of the many McCoy families on the Kentucky side. He married Sarah McCoy, often called Sally, who was his first cousin, a common arrangement in the mountains at the time. They settled on Blackberry Creek in Pike County, where they farmed, raised hogs and raised a very large family. Most accounts give them sixteen children, though the exact number varies.
His brother Asa Harmon McCoy fought for the Union in the Civil War and was shot dead after coming home in 1865. Men associated with the Confederate home guard of Devil Anse Hatfield were suspected. The killing left the McCoys with a grievance against the Hatfields long before the feud's best-known events.
The hog and the romance
In 1878 Randolph accused Floyd Hatfield of having one of his hogs. The case went before a Hatfield justice of the peace and a jury drawn from both families, and Floyd won. Randolph never accepted the verdict, as told in the 1878 hog trial.
Two years later his daughter Roseanna began her relationship with Devil Anse's son Johnse Hatfield and went to live across the river. Randolph, by most accounts, would not forgive her, and the affair ended unhappily. Roseanna's story is in Johnse and Roseanna.
The losses of 1882 and 1888
On election day in August 1882, three of Randolph's sons, Tolbert, Pharmer and Randolph Jr., called Bud, fought with Ellison Hatfield on Blackberry Creek and wounded him fatally. The three brothers were taken from Kentucky officers by a Hatfield party, and after Ellison died they were tied to pawpaw bushes on the Kentucky bank of the Tug and shot. Bud was about fifteen. Randolph and Sarah buried the three together.
Another stop · Blackberry CreekNew Year's night, 1888On the night of 1 January 1888, a Hatfield party attacked and burned the McCoy home. Randolph's daughter Alifair was shot dead, his son Calvin was killed, and Sarah was beaten and badly injured. Randolph escaped into the dark. In one night the family lost two more children and the home they had lived in for decades.
Roseanna died young, around 1889, and many accounts say she never recovered from the loss of Johnse and of the child she had with him. Her death is not counted among the feud's killings, but Randolph's family counted it as another loss.
Later years in Pikeville
After the New Year's raid, Randolph and Sarah moved to Pikeville, the Pike County seat, and never went back to Blackberry Creek to live. He is said to have run a ferry on the Big Sandy at Pikeville for a time. He lived to see the trials of 1889, at which several men were convicted for the killings of his children, and the hanging of Ellison Mounts in 1890 for the murder of Alifair.
Accounts of his last years describe a man who never let go of what had happened. He is said to have spoken of the feud to anyone who would listen and to have remained bitter toward the Hatfields to the end. Given what he had lost, that is hard to wonder at. Sarah died some years before him, her health never fully restored after the 1888 attack.
Randolph McCoy died in Pikeville in March 1914, at the age of about eighty-eight, from burns suffered in an accident at a cooking fire. He had outlived Devil Anse's brother Ellison by more than thirty years and outlived most of the men on both sides who had fought in the feud.
The grave at Dils Cemetery
Randolph and Sarah McCoy are buried in Dils Cemetery, on the hillside above downtown Pikeville. The cemetery is old and historically significant in its own right, and it is covered in Dils Cemetery, Pikeville. Their children killed in 1882 and 1888 lie in the family cemetery near the old home on Blackberry Creek, not with their parents.
The graves are visited often, and the family has asked over the years that visitors behave as they would at any burial ground. Walk on the paths, do not touch or lean on stones, take nothing and leave nothing beyond, if you wish, a simple flower.
How the family remembers
For a long time the feud was something both families preferred not to talk about. Over the years descendants have come to see it differently, and members of both families have met in public to mark the peace between them. They have also pushed back against cartoon versions of their ancestors and asked that the dead be treated as people rather than characters.
Randolph McCoy's story is the clearest reminder of why that matters. He was not a symbol but a father who lost child after child. Reading his life next to that of Devil Anse Hatfield shows two men shaped by the same valley and the same war, and the very different prices they paid.
Back to The two families
